Choosing Which Dry Cow Product Should Be Used

There are a number of dry cow antibiotics that are available and the choice of which one should be used can be difficult. The products differ in their active ingredients, the dose of antibiotic, the size of antibiotic particles, duration of action, and price.

So which products should be used?

    The choice of which product used should be made based on:
  • Mastitis history of the farm
  • Which bacteria have been causing infections this season and in the past
  • Amount of clinical mastitis experienced during the calving period
  • BMCC
  • The length of dry period given to cows
  • Price.
While many people select the dry cow products based on price, the price difference between the cheapest and the most expensive products is less significant than the cost of additional mastitis cases, or of having a poorer cure rate.

The following example is for a herd of 200 cows. The estimated cost of a case of clinical mastitis is $150 (range $120-$180). If the difference in price between two products was $4 per cow, and the more expensive product had a better cure rate (10%), provided greater protection to cows from developing mastitis at calving, this product would only have to prevent 6 cases of mastitis for the season to pay for itself.

Products:

Cepravin Dry Cow:
cepravin is best used if the bacteria Streptococcus uberis is responsible for a majority of clinical cases or if you get a lot of mastitis at calving (greater than 3 cases per 50 cows calved). Cows treated with Cepravin DC must have a dry period of 8 weeks or greater.
Orbenin Enduro / Elaclox Extra:
600 mg Cloxacillin products with small antibiotic particle size have the highest reported cure rates for Staphylococcus aureus.

Orbenin Enduro is best used where there are numerous cows with chronic Staph infections, where the BMCC is frequently greater than 250000 or there are a large number of cows with high cell counts.

Cows treated with Enduro or Elaclox Extra must have a minimum dry period of 35 days.

Orbenin / Elaclox / Noroclox:
contain a lower dose of cloxacillin than Enduro or Elaclox Extra (500mg versus 600mg) and bacteriological cure rates have been reported to be lower than Orbenin Enduro. Cows Treated with the 500mg cloxacillin products require a minimum dry period of 30 days.

 



Click here to view the rest of the 1999 April newsletter.